Nature Publishing Group, publisher of Nature, and other science journals and reference works NATURE.COM http://www.nature.com/news/ NATUREJOBS NATUREEVENTS ABOUT NPG
help Help site index Nature.com site index  
news at nature.com - the best in science journalism
USERNAME: PASSWORD:
SEARCH  Advanced search
my account e-alerts subscribe register
Home
News
Features
Columns & blogs
 Archive Archive
Specials
In focus
Stories by subject

NEWS CHANNELS
My news
Biotechnology
Careers
Drug discovery
Earth and environment
Medical Research
Physical Sciences


naturejobs

Feedback
About this site
About us
For librarians
Parasite infiltrates fruitfly research
05 July 2005

Self-hypnosis squelches allergies
05 July 2005

Ancient 'footprints' found in Mexico
04 July 2005

Twins grow apart as they age
04 July 2005

Alcohol fuels not so green
01 July 2005

Artists and scientists conspire at conference
01 July 2005

NPG PROMOTION

News
Published online: 1 July 2005; | doi:10.1038/news050627-16

Artists and scientists conspire at conference

Philip Ball
Cartoons and morphing software may help to convey scientists' finds.


Sometimes a simple cartoon is the best way to get an idea across. Click here to see an example.

© Larry Gonick / LG
"We must do this more often" was the constant refrain at a gathering of scientists, artists, film makers, designers, writers, editors and art historians at a meeting in Los Angeles. They were there to explore the use of images in science, for both understanding data and communicating it to others.

Image and Meaning 2, held from 23 to 25 June at the Getty art museum, was the successor to the first conference of this sort, staged in 2001 at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in Boston.

The conference series is the brainchild of Felice Frankel, a science photographer working at MIT. Frankel helps scientists present their work using imagery that is both informative and striking. Her photographs have graced many covers of Nature and Science.

Frankel convened the meeting because, she says, "we have a serious problem. There is an assumption that in science our graphics communicate. But they often don't." Frankel argues that many scientists don't see imagery as an integral part of the scientific process. This, she says, is doing the community a disservice.

Animated discussion

Many at the conference tackled the notion of how best to find patterns within their data. Creating graphs or maps becomes more challenging as the data get more complicated. Some have turned results into animations to wring meaning from them, whereas others have displayed their work using virtual reality 'rooms'.

 There is an assumption that in science our graphics communicate - but they don't. 

Felice Frankel
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
There is now a wealth of computer tools for generating sophisticated imagery. But scientists at the meeting complained that many of these programs never get beyond the computer-graphics community that develops them.

The audience was impressed when David Salesin, a computer scientist at the University of Washington, presented the interactive visual tools that he is developing for Microsoft. Salesin showed software that can construct realistic-looking aerial photographs from maps after being trained with a few real photo/map combinations. He also had programs that could blend different faces, and automatically turn random objects into 'Escher tiles': these are shapes that can be rotated to fill a space without leaving any gaps (see some Escher tiles here).

Salesin's methods got many researchers thinking about new ways of looking at their findings. But they also raised a host of questions about proper limits to the manipulation of images. "I had not realised how easy it is to make changes in images seamlessly," says chemist George Whitesides of Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts. He says the community should work out rules for what is acceptable in 'improving' images for publication.

Simple scribbles

On the opposite side of the coin, many argued that low-tech imagery can have advantages over high-tech in communicating research. A very polished image, says Frankel, can discourage a viewer from engaging with and thinking about a work. "If something is raw, it gives the viewer permission to participate," she says. Beautiful, computer-generated renderings can also mislead viewers, some argue, giving a false sense of certainty about the ideas they represent.

Cartoonist and self-described "lapsed mathematician" Larry Gonick argued that cartoons can be used to great effect in communicating science without having to turn to expensive or complicated techniques. "Cartooning's graphic style has certain features conducive to explanation," argues Gonick. "It invites the eye and draws the reader to the 'main character' of the illustration," he says. It also comes with a widely understood visual language, he argues, that can convey motion or narrative.

"Even the biggest-brained scientists at this conference have confessed an inability to comprehend some complex diagrams," says Gonick. Sometimes, he says, what one needs to understand a concept is a story.

 Top
For full access to the site and the archive, subscribe here:
To receive all the daily news in your inbox each week, sign up for our email alert here:
  To see the latest news visit our homepage:

 Top
Send to a friend
Printer format
e-alerts
Recommend to your library
live newsfeeds
relateds
The big picture 
31 January 2005

Image manipulation: CSI: cell biology 
20 April 2005

Amateurs beat space agencies to Titan pictures 
19 January 2005

Ethicists urge caution over emotive power of brain scans 
18 May 2005
linkout
Image and Meaning 2

Salesin's work

Larry Gonick's cartoons

ADVERTISEMENT
Identical Twins Exhibit Differences in Gene Expression

Feeling the Pinch

Psyching Out Evolutionary Psychology: Interview with David J. Buller

Climate Change Could Set Dunes in Motion, Study Suggests

more
 

news at nature

ISSN: 1744-7933
Home | News | Features | Columns and blogs | Archive news | Specials | In focus | Stories by subject |
My news | Biotechnology news | Careers news | Drug discovery news | Earth and environment news | Medical Research news | Physical sciences news |
Feedback | About this site | About us | For librarians
Nature Publishing Group, publisher of Nature, and other science journals and reference works ©2005 Nature Publishing Group | Privacy policy